If you're a dedicated cat parent, you know that finding the right litter box is essential for your cat’s comfort and your own convenience. The Modkat XL Litter Box has been making waves in the litter box market, but is it really worth the hype? Let's dive into the pros, cons, and explore some alternatives.
Here at tuft + paw, we are cat experts. We're intimately familiar with the litter box features that are most important to cats and cat parents alike. This article is based on consultation with a veterinarian, cat behaviorist, online reviews, and our own experience as cat parents to determine which litter boxes offer the best performance.
Modkat XL Litter Box Cheat Sheet
| Pros | large size, top & side entry, liner & scoop included, modern design, high walls |
| Cons | pricey, some fragile components, semi-covered, limited visibility, limited ventilation |
| Rating | 4.7/5 with 850 Amazon reviews |
| Size | 21"L x 16.3"W x 17"H |
| Materials | plastic, nylon |
| Price | $180 |
Pros of Modkat Litter Box
High Sides Prevent Litter Tracking
One standout feature of the Modkat Litter Box is its high sides, making it a great litter box for preventing litter tracking. Whether your cat is a meticulous digger or has a penchant for high-aiming bathroom activities, the Modkat helps to keep the mess contained.
Tip: Pair a high walled litter box with a low tracking pellet litter for a serious one-two punch against litter tracking.
Liner & Scoop Included
The convenience factor is high with the Modkat. It comes with two reusable nylon liners—one for top entry, and one for front entry. Plus, an included scoop means you have the essential tools on hand for daily maintenance.
Modern Design
Cats don’t care much for aesthetics, but cat parents sure do. The Modkat doesn't just focus on functionality; it brings a modern and stylish design to the table. For cat parents who appreciate blending their cat's essentials into their home decor, the Modkat is a solid option.
Large Size
Cats come in various shapes and sizes, and the Modkat takes this into consideration. With dimensions of 21"L x 16.3"W x 17"H, it offers ample space, catering to the comfort of most cats.
Accessible Entry
The Modkat provides flexibility with its setup, allowing for both top and front entry. This thoughtful design feature considers the preferences of cats of all ages and mobilities, ensuring easy access.
Cons of Modkat Litter Box
Durability Issues
Some cat parents have reported durability concerns, particularly with thinner components like the top lip. While the design is sleek, it may sacrifice sturdiness in certain areas, leading to potential breakage. For the price, we would hope to see higher quality plastic.
Limited Visibility and Ventilation
The Modkat's semi-covered design may pose a challenge in terms of visibility and ventilation. Cats often prefer having a clear line of sight while doing their business, and the partially enclosed nature of the Modkat might not align with their instincts. The semi-covered design also holds in odors more than an open top litter box, which can create an unpleasant experience for cats using it.
Pricey
The Modkat Litter Box comes with a hefty price tag of $180. While its features are impressive, cat parents on a budget might find this investment a bit steep.
Below, we’ve included some potential alternatives to the Modkat in a similar price range. Each model has its own pros and cons, so it’s up to you to determine which litter box design is best for your home.
Modkat Litter Box Alternatives
tuft + paw Cove Litter Box
For those prioritizing litter tracking prevention, the tuft + paw Cove Litter Box emerges as a top contender. With excellent build quality, a translucent scatter shield, and integrated cleaning tools, it competes strongly with the Modkat at a similar price point. For cat parents and cats who prefer an open top litter box, the Cove is as good as it gets.
Pros: excellent build quality, durable anti-stick materials, large size, high sides to limit tracking, easy to clean, accessible entry, well-ventilated, good visibility, stylish design, cleaning tools included
Cons: pricey
Price: $149-$199
Rating: 4.8/5 with 670 reviews
Size: 26"L x 16"W x 6.5"H (+8" with scatter shield)
Materials: Double-walled thick matte plastic, rubber base
tuft + paw Cubby Litter Box
An honorable mention goes to the Cubby Litter Box from tuft + paw. Sharing many strengths with the Cove, it offers a more affordable option by excluding some deluxe features. Still, it stands tall in terms of reducing litter tracking.
Pros: great build quality, durable anti-stick materials, large size, high sides to limit tracking, easy to clean, accessible entry, well-ventilated, good visibility, stylish design
Cons: pricey
Price: $69
Rating: 5/5 with 32 reviews
Size: 21.2"L x 15.2"W x 6"H (+8" with scatter shield)
Materials: Thick matte anti-stick plastic
iPrimio Stainless Steel Litter Box
If durability is your primary concern, the iPrimio Stainless Steel Litter Box presents a robust alternative. Made from stainless steel, it tackles the challenge of being both easy to clean and resistant to wear and tear, even if it comes with a relatively high price. It doesn’t have the modern style of the other options, but it’s very practical and effective.
Pros: durable materials, large size, easy to clean, high sides, accessible entry, well-ventilated, good visibility
Cons: pricey, heavy
Price: $143
Rating: 4.6/5 with 9,200 Amazon reviews
Size: 23.5"L x 15.5"W x 6"H (+ 6" w/ scatter shield)
Materials: Stainless steel and plastic
Conclusion
In conclusion, whether the Modkat Litter Box is worth it depends on your specific priorities and budget. While it boasts innovative features and a modern design, it's crucial to weigh the potential downsides against alternatives in the market. Always consider your cat's preferences and your own lifestyle before making the splurge on a litter box.
Modkat Litter Box FAQs
Is the Modkat Litter Box suitable for large cats?
Yes, the Modkat Litter Box is designed with a spacious dimension of 21"L x 16.3"W x 17"H, providing ample room for most cats to move comfortably. As a covered litter box, it may be cramped for really large cats.
Can I use my own liners with the Modkat Litter Box, or do I have to buy specific ones?
While Modkat provides reusable nylon liners designed for top and front entry, some users have successfully made their own liners with tarp. Just make sure they fit properly to ensure decent functionality.
How effective are the high sides of Modkat Litter Box in preventing litter tracking?
The high sides of the Modkat Litter Box are designed to limit litter scatter, especially when cats dig or aim high during their bathroom activities. While it's effective for many, individual cat behavior may vary.
Is the Modkat Litter Box easy to clean?
Yes, the Modkat Litter Box is equipped with features that simplify cleaning. The inclusion of a scoop and reusable liners streamlines daily maintenance, offering convenience to cat parents.
Are there common durability issues with the Modkat Litter Box, and how long does it typically last?
Some users have reported concerns about durability, particularly with thinner components like the top lip. The lifespan of the Modkat Litter Box can vary depending on usage and cat behavior, but proper care can contribute to its longevity.
