The world of feline hygiene has come a long way, with the advent of crystal cat litter revolutionizing the litter box game. Yet, with the numerous options available, choosing the right one for your cat can be challenging. Two names that often come up in the debate are Pretty Litter and Fresh Step Crystal Cat Litter. Let's dive into an in-depth comparison to determine which is the superior crystal litter.
Tip: For another brand comparison, see Genius Litter vs Really Great Cat Litter.
Price Point
|
Pretty Litter: Priced at $4.00/lb ($24 for 6 lbs)
Fresh Step: Priced more affordably at $2.43/lb ($38.84 for 16 lbs) |
Primary Ingredients
|
Pretty Litter: Features silica gel and color-changing compounds to monitor cat health.
Fresh Step: Utilizes silica gel with added fragrance and color. |
Pros and Cons
Both Pretty Litter and Fresh Step are generally high performing litters, but each brand has its own weaknesses. If you need a primer on silica gel/crystal litter, check out the pros and cons of crystal litter.
Pretty Litter
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Fresh Step Non-Clumping Scented Crystal Litter
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
Texture and Comfort
While Pretty Litter boasts a cat-friendly texture, Fresh Step's larger crystals, although reducing tracking, might be less comfortable for cats. Stepping on them can be an unwelcome experience both for cats and humans alike.
Odor Control and Absorbency
Both litters excel in odor control, but Fresh Step has a more pronounced fan base attesting to its supreme odor control capability. Meanwhile, Pretty Litter is renowned for its absorption prowess and its unique feature that allows it to change color based on a cat’s urine, aiding in early detection of potential health issues.
Eco-friendliness
Neither litter can be labeled "eco-friendly," due to the non-biodegradable nature of silica and the environmental cost of silica mining. Both, however, edge out clay litters in longevity and non-toxicity. These litters are made with harmless silica gel, while clay litter contains crystalline silica dust—a known carcinogen when inhaled. If you prefer to buy eco-friendly products, you may prefer a natural cat litter.
Health Monitoring
An exclusive advantage of Pretty Litter is its health monitoring feature. The color-changing compounds can alert cat owners to changes in the pH and blood content of the cat’s urine, potentially indicating health issues. This feature can be invaluable for cat parents concerned about their pet’s well-being.
Additional Considerations
- Fresh Step may have slight inconsistencies, with some users reporting increased dust in recent batches.
- Fresh Step is a scented litter, which some cats may not like.
- Regular stirring is crucial for both litters to maintain optimum absorption and odor control.
The Verdict: Pretty Litter vs Fresh Step
The decision between Pretty Litter and Fresh Step is more about personal preferences and specific cat needs than a clear winner. For those prioritizing health monitoring, Pretty Litter holds an edge. If affordability and intense odor control are top concerns, Fresh Step shines bright. But, as veterinarian Megan Teiber wisely said, “the best litter is the one your cat will use.” Lastly, while the convenience of crystal litters is undeniable, consider exploring more sustainable options. Tuft + paw’s tofu litter, for instance, is sustainably harvested, biodegradable, and even flushable, merging functionality with eco-consciousness.
